Hamilton House of Pizza

Reviews

• Peter M.

  star star star star star_border 28 May 2026

  I've had my share of pizza as a traveling technician.  Always eating road food. This place is simple pizza joint that is very clean, seriously managed, and good food.
  
  I had a simple cheese pizza. Twice in a row. Not to greasy, and the sauce was good and we'll proportioned. Tons of cheese.
  
  I'm glad their here.

• David P.

  star star star star star_border 21 May 2026

  Nice simple local pizza place. Nothing over the top nothing wasted. Also good to see the local kids working here. The folks that run it are cool to talk to. They answer questions and will try to accomadate changes to menu items and orders. As long as its nothing too crazy. I give it a 4. It lacks in some spots but more than makes up for it in the attitude of the staff. I will keep getting my cravings pizza from them.

• Kara N.

  star star_border star_border star_border star_border 11 May 2026

  I always order from Hamilton House and I have always had a good experience. Today was not one of those day. I called to place an order and the woman, who I never have had answer the phone, answered and just said 'Hamilton House' didn't ask if it was pick up or delivery, which they always ask. Then she kept cutting me off when I tried to tell her want I wanted. At the end of the order, she said 'ok thanks' and hung up. Did not tell me how much it was, did not tell me how long it would be, and ESPECIALLY did not ask how I wanted to pay, which I wanted to pay by card. I then called back and politely said I did not get a chance to give her my card number. She said 'go ahead', didn't apologize for rudely hanging up on me. I almost just told her to forget it and not bring the food, but I love their food so I just decided to put up with it. I gave her my card number and she said 'ok thanks' and hung up AGAIN. I did not want to call back to ask for her name because I felt I was going to say something not very nice. Needless to say, Hamilton House was always my go to place, but they just lost my business because of some poor customer service

• Al M.

  star star star_border star_border star_border 7 May 2026

  My first time today ever ordering anything from this shop....Got a chicken Caesar wrap. Every other bite had a hard piece of chicken cartilage that I had to discard. Also I have never in my life ordered a chicken Caesar wrap that had cucumber in it so I had to pick them out. For almost $10 a sub I can safely say I won't be going back. Only plus? The Caesar dressing was awesome!

• Theodore T.

  star star star star star_border 5 May 2026

  Got some pies for takeout.  Pizza was very good, especially the crust.  More Greek style as opposed to Italian.  No complaints, prices were good as well.